Home » 2009 » Currently Reading:

Compatibility of the French draft law with EC law cannot be taken for granted

April 1, 2009 2009

The European Gaming and Betting Association (EGBA) has stated that compatibility of the French draft law with EC law cannot be taken for granted.

The Association is concerned that a series of key provisions of the draft law envisaged by the French government would conflict with the EC Treaty and the European Court of Justice (ECJ) case law:

The EGBA referred to five points:

1. How can the reform and the opening of online sports betting only be consistent when sports betting in the offline environment will remain under the monopoly of FDJ and PMU?

2. Is “French tradition” an acceptable justification to limit the opening of horse betting only to pool betting – especially when fixed odds betting is offered for all other types of sports and is very much appreciated by French and European consumers?

3. Is a ceiling on the pay-back ratio (percentage of stakes paid back to players) to the same level of those currently applied by historical operators compatible with EU law? Given that such ceiling has no proved or known impact on consumer protection, what other objectives than protection of the French market and the position of historical operators can it possibly serve?

4. Will the French online gaming authority, in compliance with the jurisprudence of the ECJ, take into account the warranties and controls already offered by other EU licensing jurisdictions such as for instance UK, Malta or Gibraltar, in order to avoid the application of dual licensing and purely administrative restrictions in the single market?

5. Is the creation of a sports betting right granted to the French sport federations in the context of commercial agreements with sports betting operators in France a credible means to prevent match fixing? The majority of stakeholders have already developed partnerships and successful early warning systems to anticipate and prevent those risks.

For its part, the EGBA is particularly concerned about “the threat of the creation of a local Internet market for online betting and gaming services given the French authorities’ clear intention to adopt payment and ISP blockings and the continued criminal enforcement against EU established online gaming and betting operators”.

The Associated stated that this would be completely incompatible with the European dimension and the cross-border nature of this leading internet sector.

According to Sigrid Ligné, secretary general of the EGBA: “The notification procedure is a great tool to anticipate potential conflicts. We are convinced that the recommendations that will be addressed to France by June will facilitate the French Parliament’s discussions and prevent unnecessary litigation once the law comes into force.”

The French government notified its draft law recently to Commissioner Verheugen’s services in the context of a preliminary conformity test with EU Law. Member States and the European Commission have until the June 8 to examine whether the law is in conformity with the rules of the EC Treaty and to require, if necessary, amendments to be made so as to avoid future litigation.

GamingLaw

Posted by:

Legal Gaming in Europe Summit 2013 – Summary Day 1

Legal Gaming in Europe Summit 2013 Day 1 Summary Video







Video: International Gaming Law Summit 2011 Highlights

International Gaming Law Summit 2011 Highlights Video



Copyright: http://www.calvinayre.com

To get the latest news follow us on

twitterlinkedintwitterlinkedin

Archives